Guillotine League Week 6 is here, and managers are running out of time to make excuses for players who aren’t helping them survive.
Welcome back to another week of Guillotine fantasy football, where a good roster isn’t enough. You need a roster that scores enough points every single week to avoid the chopping block. That’s the entire game.
In a traditional fantasy league, you can be patient. You can hold a struggling player another week, wait for an offense to get healthy, or stash talent because you believe better days are coming. In a Guillotine or Chop League, patience can get expensive. Every week the lowest-scoring team is eliminated, and its entire roster becomes available to the surviving managers. The longer you last, the better the waiver wire can become. That means every roster spot matters.
This week I’m breaking the Week 6 decisions into three categories: Undroppable Players, Tough Decisions, and Obvious Drops. Some players shouldn’t even require a discussion. Others will make you uncomfortable. And then there are the players where I’m willing to forget everything I thought I knew about their future just to get through Sunday.
Let’s get to it.
Undroppable Players in Guillotine Leagues for Week 6
Some decisions in Guillotine fantasy football are difficult. These aren’t.
If you roster any of the following players, it should take an extraordinary circumstance to consider cutting them. These are elite fantasy assets who can deliver the kind of weekly production that keeps you away from the chopping block.
1. Jahmyr Gibbs — Undroppable
Gibbs is the type of running back you want anchoring a Guillotine roster. He offers explosive rushing production, receiving work, and the ability to turn an ordinary afternoon into a massive score. You don’t cut a player like Gibbs because of one disappointing week or a difficult matchup. Keep him. Don’t get cute.
2. Ja’Marr Chase — Undroppable
Chase is another obvious keep. In Guillotine leagues you want players who can put up huge numbers without needing everything to go perfectly, and Chase has the talent and ceiling to deliver exactly that. Even if he has a quiet afternoon, the possibility of a monster performance is always there. You don’t throw away an elite wide receiver because you’re worried about one week’s score. Chase stays. End of discussion.
3. Justin Jefferson — Undroppable
If Justin Jefferson is on your roster, you’re holding him. Elite wide receivers become especially valuable as the competition tightens and the waiver wire gets more expensive. Jefferson can deliver the kind of receiving performance that separates survival from elimination. Could he have a frustrating week? Of course. Could he post a huge game when you need it most? Absolutely. That’s why you keep him.
4. Amon-Ra St. Brown — Undroppable
St. Brown belongs in the same conversation. He’s the high-end receiver you want in your lineup when the margin for error shrinks. His role in the Detroit offense makes him a player you should be building around, not shopping for a replacement.
The Week 6 rule for these four is simple: Gibbs, Chase, Jefferson, and St. Brown are not the players you should be worrying about cutting. Save the difficult decisions for the players who actually deserve the debate.
Tough Guillotine League Decisions: When Surviving Sunday Matters More
This is where Guillotine strategy gets interesting. These players have real value, but that doesn’t automatically make them untouchable. The key is separating long-term value from what you need to survive this week.
1. Tee Higgins — Do Not Drop
After Higgins’ latest four-point performance, you might be tempted to move on. Don’t. He’s currently WR14 in Masters scoring and is attached to one of the league’s most talented passing offenses alongside Ja’Marr Chase and Joe Burrow. One bad fantasy week doesn’t erase that value.
The danger in Guillotine leagues is that a disappointing performance can make you question players you should still want. You start scanning the waiver wire, see someone coming off a big game, and convince yourself a replacement is safer. Sometimes it is. But don’t confuse one bad result with a player suddenly becoming expendable. Higgins has the talent and offensive environment to bounce back. If you cut him now, there’s a good chance another manager will be happy to take advantage.
My call: Do not drop Tee Higgins. You don’t have to love his latest score to recognize the upside you’d be giving away.
2. Chase Brown — Do Not Drop
Chase Brown hasn’t lived up to his draft position yet, and the frustration is understandable. When you invest heavily in a running back, you want production, not Sundays spent wondering whether the workload will turn into fantasy points. But Brown is still tied to an offense featuring Burrow, Chase, and Higgins. That environment gives him a clear path to valuable production if his role and efficiency improve.
This is where Guillotine managers need to think carefully before cutting bait. Running backs who can become major contributors in strong offenses are difficult to replace. If Brown finally puts together the game you’ve been waiting for, you don’t want to be the manager who gave up one week too early. Is he an automatic start regardless of matchup? Not necessarily. Is he an automatic cut because he hasn’t justified his draft capital? Absolutely not.
My call: Do not drop Chase Brown. Give him more time unless your roster situation becomes desperate.
3. Joe Burrow — The Crazy Call: Drop Him and Try to Buy Him Back
Now we’re getting uncomfortable. My advice is to consider dropping Joe Burrow if you need the roster spot and the immediate quarterback points to survive Week 6. Yes, Burrow, the same quarterback driving the passing offense that makes Higgins and Chase so appealing.
I know how strange that sounds. But Guillotine football forces decisions that would seem ridiculous in a normal redraft league. Quarterback points matter. If your current roster isn’t producing enough at the position, you need a way to put a competitive score on the board. Burrow’s name and long-term value don’t help you if you’re eliminated this week.
If you have a better immediate quarterback option available and need the roster spot to strengthen another position, I’m willing to make the cut. The plan isn’t necessarily to give up on Burrow permanently. It’s to survive Week 6, then try to get him back off waivers next week if the opportunity is there — which is where smart Guillotine FAAB strategy pays off.
There is risk: another manager could claim him, and you might never get another chance. That’s the gamble. But if the alternative is keeping a valuable quarterback while your overall lineup struggles to score enough points, sometimes you have to make the uncomfortable move. In a Guillotine League there are no bonus points for having the most recognizable names on your bench.
My call: Drop Burrow only if the immediate lineup improvement is worth the risk. Then make him a waiver priority next week.
4. Sam LaPorta — Keep Him, or Stream Two Tight Ends to Survive
Sam LaPorta is currently TE3 in Masters scoring. Ordinarily that’s a pretty convincing reason to keep him. He’s producing like a high-end fantasy tight end, and the position can be difficult to replace. But I’m not convinced he can maintain this level of consistency with all the other weapons competing for opportunities in Detroit. That doesn’t mean LaPorta is a bad player. It means I’m looking at the opportunity cost of keeping him in a Guillotine League.
If I already have another strong tight end available, I’m much more comfortable keeping LaPorta and riding it out. But if I don’t have another reliable option, I’m willing to get creative. If I can improve my immediate lineup by streaming two tight ends and using the roster spots to chase more points this week, I’m willing to drop LaPorta and try to buy him back later.
That is an aggressive move, and it’s not one I’d make automatically. LaPorta’s current production gives him real value, so I need a clear reason to believe the alternatives improve my chances of surviving. But that’s the Guillotine mindset: you aren’t protecting draft capital or trying to win a season-long popularity contest. You’re trying to score enough points this week.
My call: Keep LaPorta if you have a reliable backup. If you need to stream two tight ends to cover the position and strengthen your lineup, I’m willing to make the cut and revisit him on waivers.
Obvious Guillotine League Drops: The Entire Miami Dolphins Roster Is on Notice
This is the section where we’re going to have a little fun.
If you’ve been holding onto Miami Dolphins players because you’re waiting for the offense to turn things around, I have a question: how many more weeks are you willing to wait?
In a Guillotine League you don’t have the luxury of holding an entire offense because you believe the talent should eventually produce. At some point the results have to show up. Right now I’m looking at the Dolphins as a team where I’d rather use my roster spots on players who can help me survive this week. That means I’m willing to cut virtually the entire Miami roster.
Yes, the entire roster. Quarterbacks? I’m looking elsewhere. Receivers? I’m looking elsewhere. Other skill-position players? Unless somebody gives me a compelling reason to keep him, I’m moving on.
What About Ollie Gordon?
Ollie Gordon is probably the one Miami player who might tempt me to stay patient. But even there, I’m not interested in holding him simply because of what he might become. If Gordon isn’t giving me the immediate production I need, I’m willing to cut him and add another running back who can help me survive Week 6.
I can worry about Gordon’s future another time. I can worry about the upside another time. I can worry about whether Miami figures things out another time. Right now I’m worried about not getting chopped.
If another running back gives me a better chance to score points this week, I’m making the move. And if Ollie Gordon eventually breaks out after I drop him? Good for him. I hope somebody else enjoys the production. I’ll be busy trying to survive another Sunday.
That’s the beauty — and the frustration — of Guillotine fantasy football. Sometimes you have to make a move that looks terrible in a season-long projection but makes perfect sense when your only goal is to avoid elimination. (If that idea still feels wrong, read our Guillotine fantasy football strategy guide.)
Week 6 Guillotine League Strategy: Make the Move Before It’s Too Late
The biggest mistake you can make in a Guillotine League is treating every roster decision like a traditional fantasy football decision. It isn’t. You need to separate the players you simply cannot afford to lose from the players whose value depends on your current roster, your available replacements, and the points you need this week.
Here’s how I’m approaching Week 6:
- Undroppable: Jahmyr Gibbs, Ja’Marr Chase, Justin Jefferson, and Amon-Ra St. Brown.
- Tough decisions: Keep Tee Higgins and Chase Brown. Consider cutting Joe Burrow if a better immediate quarterback option can help you survive. Evaluate Sam LaPorta based on your available tight ends and potential streaming options.
- Obvious drops: I’m willing to move on from virtually the entire Miami Dolphins roster, including Ollie Gordon, if another running back offers a better chance of helping me survive this week.
Remember, every team that gets chopped adds another full roster of players to the waiver wire. That’s why you need to keep improving your lineup instead of protecting players just because you drafted them early. You can always try to acquire a player again later. You cannot get back into the league after your team is eliminated.
Final Word: Survive Week 6
Week 6 is about knowing which players deserve your patience and which ones are taking up space you need right now.
Keep your elite players. Don’t panic over one bad performance from Higgins or Brown. Be willing to make difficult decisions with Burrow and LaPorta if the right replacements are available. And if the Miami offense keeps giving you reasons to look elsewhere, don’t be afraid to move on.
The waiver wire will keep getting stronger as teams are eliminated. Your job is to take advantage of those opportunities while making sure you’re still standing next week.
In Guillotine fantasy football, you don’t have to win every argument about player value. You just have to score enough points to survive. And if that means making a move that looks crazy on paper? Sometimes that’s exactly what the commish ordered.
Guillotine League Week 6 FAQ
Should I drop Tee Higgins in a Guillotine League?
No. Despite a four-point week, Higgins is WR14 in Masters scoring and plays in one of the NFL’s most talented passing offenses with Ja’Marr Chase and Joe Burrow. One bad week doesn’t erase that value, and another manager will gladly scoop him up.
Should I drop Joe Burrow in a Guillotine League?
Only if you have a better immediate quarterback option and need the roster spot to survive Week 6. The plan is to survive this week and then try to buy Burrow back off waivers, knowing another manager could claim him first.
Should I drop Sam LaPorta?
Keep LaPorta if you have a reliable backup tight end. If you don’t, streaming two tight ends and using the roster spots to chase more points this week is an aggressive but reasonable Guillotine move, with the option to revisit LaPorta on waivers.
Should I drop Miami Dolphins players in Guillotine leagues?
In a Guillotine League, you can’t wait for an offense to figure things out. Virtually the entire Dolphins roster is droppable this week, including Ollie Gordon, if another player gives you a better chance to score points and survive.
How does elimination work in a Guillotine League?
Each week, the lowest-scoring team in the league is eliminated, and its entire roster goes to the waiver wire for the surviving managers. That’s why the waiver wire keeps getting stronger as the season goes on, and why every roster spot matters. New to the format? Start with our beginner’s guide to Guillotine fantasy football.
Play Guillotine Fantasy Football at Masters Fantasy Football Leagues
Looking for a competitive Guillotine League, Chop League, or high-stakes fantasy football league? Masters Fantasy Football Leagues has been running fantasy football leagues since 2008, giving players a place to compete with experienced commissioners and real support throughout the season.
Masters has filled more than 20,000 fantasy football leagues and paid out over $34 million, with no league ever folding since 2008. Whether you enjoy Guillotine fantasy football, dynasty fantasy football, or high-dollar redraft leagues, Masters offers all-in pricing with no hidden fees and live commissioner support from people who understand the game.
Drafts run seven days a week, from noon to midnight, giving you plenty of opportunities to find your next league.
Ready to compete? Check out our Guillotine League rules and schedule or visit MastersFantasyFootballLeagues.com to join a league today.
